Bite marks are tricky because theyre about more than just the teeth. These physical traces frequently include blood and other bodily fluids, hair, fibers, and even bite marks. Bite marks, like fingerprints, are unique forensic odontologistwill make a cast or take pictures of the bite marks types of bites a clear impression means that there was significant pressure. Bite mark analysis is also controversial because dental profiles are subject to change. If a victim is bitten by a perpetrator during a crime and police have a suspect, odontologists can attempt to match the bite mark to the suspects teeth. But when cooper asked if theres any way bite mark analysis can be. The aims of this study are to evaluate the accuracy of two methods for bite mark analysis overlay and docking techniques on three different food materials. In the present study, we found that xerographic method is more accurate and inexpensive, and can be used for preliminary screening purposes. I have written master thesis about different methods in bitemark analysis. Bite mark analysis criminal cases many times call for the examination of evidence that can tie a suspect or victim to a crime scene or to one another.
Bite mark analysis assumes the uniqueness of the dentition can be accurately recorded on skin or an object. During the crime, bundy left a bite mark on the buttocks of lisa levy, whom he raped and killed. Man wrongly convicted with bite mark evidence confronts bite. Pretty and freemans study is a major development in the field of bite mark analysis. Bite mark analysis is conducted by comparing a sample such as a bite mark left on the victims skin to a sample taken from the defendant through impressions or photographs, and comparing the unique features of both in order to determine whether the defendant left the original mark. Bite mark analysis has been used as a means of identifying the culprit for over a century. How the flawed science of bite mark analysis has sent. However, further research on bite mark comparison is needed to enhance the reliability and accuracy of bite mark analysis. Bite mark analysis and comparison is a complicated matter. This project has been created with explain everything interactive whiteboard for windows.
Bites from animals are rarely the object of bite mark analysis. The ted bundy case is what allowed bitemark analysis to hit the big time, fabricant said. As for the fields methods of collecting and recording bite marks, its true. Its one youd think would attract the attention of the committee charged with investigating whether bite mark analysis is suitable for court. In the case of a deceased person, the bite mark may be excised for further forensic bite mark analysis or the whole body may be taken to a facility where it will be examined. Bite marks occur primarily in sexrelated crimes, child abuse cases, and offenses involving physical altercations, such as. The notorious serial killer was executed after a trial in florida in 1979 at which a forensic dentist.
Aug 19, 2016 bite mark analysis includes description of bite marks, bite mark recognition, bite mark registration, evidence collection on suspects, scanning bite mark photographs, detecting and correcting photographic distortion, resizing the photograph, printing and enhancing and adding text, scanning suspects casts, overlay fabrication, comparison methods, guidelines on bite mark analysis and management. The assumption that the human dentition is unique plays an important role in this process. Bite marks are accepted as being unique to each person since the characteristics of bite mark may be affected by the type, number, and peculiarities of the teeth, dynamics of occlusion, muscle function, individual tooth movement and temporomandibular joint dysfunction. Bite mark evidence deemed unreliable innocence project. That report found that bite mark analysis lacks scientific validity. The scandinavian countries were using bite mark evidence many years. To analyse and compare a bite mark left on human skin with a suspects dentition is a difficult procedure. Bite mark analysis article about bite mark analysis by the.
By the 1980s, the technique had gained widespread judicial acceptance. Bite marks analysis is a vital area in forensic odontology, which constitutes the commonest form of dental evidence presented in criminal court. Bite mark management and analysis master of forensic. In this section, students leave dental impressions on several pieces of candy, and study each others candy to determine who made the bite marks. A second study, undertaken by the presidents counsel of advisory on science and technology pcast, came to even stronger conclusions in 2016, finding bitemark analysis does not meet the scientific standards for foundational validity, and is far from meeting such standards. Jul 17, 20 fortunately, the practice of bite mark analysis in determining evidence in a criminal case may be eliminated soon depending upon a new york judges ruling.
Bitemark analysis is used widely in the judicial system to establish a connection between the suspect and a crime. The onset of oral diseases such as dental caries has been shown to alter the arch and tooth configuration and must be taken into account. Analysis of bitemark bitemark analysis is extremely complex, with many factors involved in a forensic dentists ability to determine the identity of the perpetrator. In these records you will find the most recent and the most authoritative articles on the topics, people and events that are shaping the criminal justice conversation. Use of bite mark evidence in the courtroom can be traced back to 1692, but it was wasnt until 1984 that the american board of forensic odontology established guidelines for bite mark analysis. The results of the bite mark comparison may indicate a perfect or reasonably perfect fit between the bite. Although the chi omega murder trial had bitemark evidence as its centerpiece, its usually used in conjunction with other types of physical evidence. Bite mark has a place evidence in crimescene analysis cases shown on forensic tv shows reveal bite mark evidence as conclusive and leading to identification of a perpetrator slideshow 1518359 by shina. I was interested to know about the role of dental professionals in forensic team and how dental findings can serve the justice system. Dna analysis has shed some light on the limitations of bite mark analysis because often the dna from saliva surrounding the area of the bite mark proves to be a more reliable form of identification. Human bite mark analysis is by far the most demanding and complicated part of forensic.
These casts can be made from a variety of materials like silicon rubber, plastic, and powders. Abfo bitemark methodology standards and guid elin s. Courts have admitted bite mark comparison evidence in homicide, rape, and child abuse cases. Forensic dentists can tell a lot about someone from his or her teeth or from bitemarks, but the analysis can be flawed or misleading.
Moreover, some courts speak of bite mark comparison as a science. If so, share your ppt presentation slides online with. The uniqueness of the human dentition has not been scientifically established. Reasons why the use of bite mark evidence should not be. However, biting is a dynamic procedure involving three moving systems, the maxilla, the. Bitemark, bite mark, bitemark the meaning of the terms is clear and there is no need for the abfo to endorse a particular form. However, the analysis of bite marks is by no means new. Council concludes bitemark analysis is junk the intercept. We can use bitemarks to carry out bitemark analysis. Bourne, the dna of a suspect excluded them from the crime after a dentist claimed the bite marks on the victim. Forensic odontology an introduction to forensic dentistry is the property of its rightful owner.
Morris was a neighbor to the little girl who was found stabbed, sexually assaulted, and bitten in a field near her florida home. A human bite mark will often be elliptical or circular in formation and will display the specific characteristics of the teeth that have been used to make the mark. He spent four months in jail until dna tests proved his innocence. Bite mark analysis has been allowed into evidence in. Bitemark has a place evidence in crimescene analysis cases shown on forensic tv shows reveal bitemark. Human bite mark analysis is by far the most demanding and complicated part of forensic dentistry. Bite mark, forensic, salivary dna, dentition, suspect introduction. Feb 10, 2014 the ted bundy case is what allowed bite mark analysis to hit the big time, fabricant said. Sep 07, 2016 bitemark analysis is conducted by forensic dentists and relies on two foundational premises. The texas forensic science commission has recommended that courts place a moratorium on the use of bite mark evidence in criminal cases, the.
Bitemark analysis is extremely complex, with many factors involved in a forensic dentists ability to determine the identity of the perpetrator. Bite mark impressions teacher information materials. Forensic dentist training as well as proper education of the jury are also factors. Use a ruler to make the measurements needed to the nearest tenth of a centimeter and record your data in the table below along with any notes regarding unique characteristics you observe in the teeth. Depending on the location of the bite, its not typical to find bite marks where both the upper and lower teeth left clear impressions, usually one or the other is more visible. Hundreds of cases have admitted this type of evidence, and no reported case has rejected it. The idea behind the method is that bite marks are like fingerprints and can be traced back to. Bite mark analysis includes description of bite marks, bite mark recognition, bite mark registration, evidence collection on suspects, scanning bite mark photographs, detecting and correcting photographic distortion, resizing the photograph, printing and enhancing and adding text, scanning suspects casts, overlay fabrication, comparison methods, guidelines on. Bite mark analysis and comparison using image perception. Bite marks can be recorded in violent crimes such as sexual. Since then, this organization has expanded its workshops to standardize the way bite mark evidence is recovered, stored, analyzed and evaluated. But even within the pattern matching disciplines, the nas report singled out bite mark matching for some especially harsh criticism. The most famous bite mark case in the us, and perhaps the world, is that of serial killer ted bundy. The study of human bite marks is an area of forensic dentistry that has attracted considerable attention in the past 10 years.
Bite mark comparison is one of the major and newer parts of this forensic discipline that has been evolving since the 1970s and has played a major role in many cases and the convictions of many criminal including the infamous ted bundy who was convicted solely on. The standard techniques for examining bite marks are based upon interpreting photographic evidence in which a bite is compared with the models of the teeth of suspects. I direct students to part 2 identification on their labs. Jun 10, 20 the field of bite mark science is expanding, and the need for individuals trained and experienced in the recognition, collection and analysis of this type of evidence is increasing. Anthony cardoza, who coauthored a 1999 study showing that bite mark analysis could be reliable under specific conditions, admitted, the best bite mark is one you can swab for dna source. Issues in human and animal bite mark bitemark analysis. Typical metric and spatial analysis of bite mark data points placed at central portion of each mark in injury. Analysis of bite marks plays an important role in personal identification in forensic casework. Likewise a bite mark will can be ushaped in appearance with a space in between to show where the biter has opened their mouth to a width necessary to get their teeth around a wrist. Cons methods of bite mark analysis bite mark analysis has been used for more than fifty years to establish a connection between a defendant and a crime. Computerbased method is considered as a gold standard for bite mark analysis.
Giannelli in criminal trials, forensic dentistry typically is used in two ways. The second procedure, bite mark analysis, has been used for more than fifty years to establish a connection between a defendant and a crime. Bite mark analysis is most commonly used in criminal rape, murder and child abuse cases. The problem of specificity in the bite mark analysis results from the lack of a scientific core of basic data for comparison. During the crime, bundy left a bite mark on the buttocks of lisa. Sep 04, 2012 the most famous bite mark case in the us, and perhaps the world, is that of serial killer ted bundy. These physical traces frequently include blood and other bodily fluids, hair, fibers, and even bite. In concluding that more research is needed to confirm the fundamental basis for the science of bite mark comparison, the nas report summarized some of the basic problems inherent in bite mark analysis and interpretation as follows.
There are countless examples of people who were convicted on the basis of bitemark analysis and later exonerated by subsequent dna evidence. Time can affect bite marks, and so can movement and pressure. Bite mark analysis photographs evidence collection e g. Infinity dental web the associated press released a story last month that revealed the appalling history behind a branch of forensic dentistry called bike mark analysis. This type of comparison is used to confirm or eliminate the identity of a suspect in relation to the bitemark. Definite bitemark there is no reasonable doubt that teeth created the pattern. About bite mark evidence forensic odontology wrongful. Now that students are familiar with basic bite mark analysis, it is time for them to apply their learning in the form of an investigation.
For lots more information about forensic dentistry and crime stuff, check out the articles and links below. This is for a high school level forensic science class. Apr 18, 2017 analysis of bite mark bite mark analysis is extremely complex, with many factors involved in a forensic dentists ability to determine the identity of the perpetrator. Aug 21, 2012 bite mark analysis and comparison using imageperception technology j forensic odontostomatol 2006. Bite site evidence general considerations the forensic odontologist is often not involved in the initial examination and collection of the bitemark evidence. These are very different procedures, and the failure to distinguish. Bitemark analysis is extremely complex, with many factors. Bite mark analysis definition of bite mark analysis by the. A bite mark will show 12 teeth severely marking the skin. Bitemark is a very peculiar and main evidence for a forensic.
Although bite marks of an individual do have uniqueness. The report found no evidence of an existing scientific basis for identifying an individual to the exclusion of all others. Ppt bite mark analysis powerpoint presentation, free. The field of bite mark science is expanding, and the need for individuals trained and experienced in the recognition, collection and analysis of this type of evidence is increasing. Since 2014, the marshall project has been curating some of the best criminal justice reporting from around the web. Forensic bite mark analysis accurate casts of the teeth must be produced. Make an impression follow the directions to create a bite mark impression. The fact is, a small group of forensic dentists are conducting bite mark analyses on these victims, and their conclusions become the determining factor in many cases.
Bite mark evidence has been introduced in trials all over the country, and sometimes has been the smoking gun leading to a conviction. Feb 16, 2017 in a 2011 interview with cnns anderson cooper, levine continued to defend bite mark analysis as important and viable. Bite mark evidence pdf this activity allows students to practice making and analyzing bite mark impressions using stryrofoam plates and a variety of soft candy. Bite mark evidence, an aspect of forensic odontology, is the process by which odontologists dentists attempt to match marks found at crime scenes with the dental impressions of suspects. The movement of a persons jaw and tongue when he or she bites contributes to the type of mark that is left. Although bite marks of an individual do have uniqueness due to specific characteristics and arrangement of the teeth, when it comes to bite mark analysis, it is complicated by numerous factors, being presented as a challenge to the forensic. Now some critics feel that bitemark analysis should be used only to eliminate, not to identify, a suspect. Ppt forensic odontology an introduction to forensic. Depending on the location of the bite, its not typical to find bite.
Conclusions from bite mark analysis can assist to answer some very crucial questions about the happenings at the crime scene thus helping judicial system. The second procedure, bite mark analysis, has been used for more than. When faced with a person who has allegedly been bitten, a history of the bite assault. Identification of a person with the help of bite mark analysis. Bite marks are not as distinctive as fingerprints or dna. The loss of teeth or the alteration of arch configuration through a variety of procedures is common in human populations. Cases where dna revealed that bite mark analysis led to. Others say that its acceptable to state there is a probability that a suspect created the mark, but that its important to clarify that bite marks cant be the only thing linking the suspect to the crime. Human bite mark analysis is most demanding and complicated part of forensic dentistry, involving identification of assailant by comparing record of their dentition with record of bite mark left on. Following is a discussion of the difference between bite mark analysis and comparison of a bite mark to a suspects dentition for purposes of identification. Many techniques to analyze bite mark patterns have been used in the past. The controversial history of bite mark analysis asda blog. Jan 23, 2008 courts have admitted bite mark comparison evidence in homicide, rape, and child abuse cases.
The committee held its first meeting on february 16. Bite mark analysis and comparison using imageperception technology j forensic odontostomatol 2006. Jan 30, 2017 in fact, the entire section on bite mark analysis is an extended argument explaining why it isnt recommended. Comparative study on two methods for bite mark analysis. Bitemark analysis is junk, white house says inverse. Bite mark analysis to determine the patterned injury is a human animal patterned injury that mimics human b m class characteristics dental arches forms that are recorded in the media, whether it be skin or an inanimate object individual characteristics pattern left by the teeth of the biter dolonak d, matches e. The second step in bite mark analysis is to determine which marks were made from which teeth. Bite marks are often observed at crime scenes on various parts of the human body, although they are more common in certain parts of the body. Analysis and identification of bite marks in forensic casework. Incredibly, prosecutors are still defending bite mark. Ppt bite mark analysis powerpoint presentation, free download.
1069 825 883 882 987 348 1202 1508 210 1066 973 209 1212 810 500 293 106 1563 446 741 853 999 1308 523 539 999 970 922 902 468 660 681 185 535 1046 147 762 1055 858